If you have been researching a trip to Iceland, chances are you have ended up on Reddit, specifically the r/visitingiceland community.
This page brings together the 20 most frequently discussed questions from real travelers, with clear, up-to-date answers to help you plan smarter and avoid common mistakes.
FAQ – Visiting Iceland Reddit
- Is Iceland really that expensive?
Yes, Iceland is expensive compared to most countries, especially for food and accommodation.
You can keep costs down by renting a car, shopping at supermarkets, and choosing self-drive travel over guided tours. - How many days do you need in Iceland?
Most Reddit users recommend:
- 3–4 days for Reykjavík and nearby areas
- 6–8 days for the South Coast or partial Ring Road
- 10–14 days for the full Ring Road
Trying to do too much in too little time is one of the most common mistakes.
- Do I need to rent a car in Iceland?
For most travelers, yes.
Public transport outside Reykjavík is limited, and many top sights are not reachable by bus. Renting a car gives you flexibility, saves time, and is often cheaper than booking multiple tours. - Is it safe to drive in Iceland?
Yes, but conditions can be challenging.
Weather changes fast, roads can be narrow, and winter driving requires extra caution. Always check road conditions and weather forecasts before driving. - Do I need a 4×4 vehicle in Iceland?
A 4×4 is not required for Reykjavík, the Golden Circle, or most of the South Coast in summer.
It is recommended in winter, for rural areas, or if road conditions are snowy or icy. - Can I drive the Ring Road in winter?
You can, but it is weather-dependent.
Many Reddit users advise flexibility, allowing extra days, and avoiding long driving distances during short daylight hours. - What is the best time of year to visit Iceland?
It depends on your priorities:
- Summer: easier driving, midnight sun, hiking
- Winter: Northern Lights, fewer crowds, winter landscapes
There is no single “best” time, only different experiences.
- Can I see the Northern Lights without a tour?
Yes.
Having a rental car allows you to escape city lights and follow the aurora forecast. Clear skies are more important than high solar activity. - Is the Blue Lagoon worth it?
Reddit opinions are mixed.
Some love it, others find it expensive and crowded. Many recommend visiting early morning or late evening, or choosing quieter geothermal alternatives. - Do I need cash in Iceland?
No.
Iceland is almost completely cashless. Credit and debit cards are accepted everywhere, including gas stations. - Is tipping expected in Iceland?
No.
Service charges are included in prices, and tipping is not expected. - What should I pack for Iceland?
Layers are essential.
Waterproof jacket, warm mid-layers, sturdy shoes, and wind protection matter more than fashion. - Are Iceland roads difficult?
Main roads are generally easy to drive.
Gravel roads require slower speeds and caution, especially for first-time visitors. - Can I visit waterfalls and sights without hiking?
Yes.
Many famous waterfalls and viewpoints are just a short walk from parking areas, making Iceland accessible even with limited mobility. - Is food expensive in Iceland?
Yes, especially restaurants.
Many travelers save money by preparing breakfast, buying snacks at supermarkets, and limiting restaurant meals. - Are there speed cameras in Iceland?
Yes, and they are strictly enforced.
Speeding fines are high, and rental cars are not exempt. - Can I camp anywhere in Iceland?
No.
Wild camping is restricted. You must use designated campsites unless you have landowner permission. - Is it safe to drink tap water in Iceland?
Yes.
Iceland’s tap water is among the cleanest in the world. No need to buy bottled water. - How bas is the weather in Iceland really?
Unpredictable.
Wind is often more challenging than cold, and sudden changes are normal. Always plan buffer time. - Is Iceland good for first-time international travelers?
Yes.
It is safe, English is widely spoken, infrastructure is excellent, and self-drive travel is straightforward with good preparation.
Why Reddit Travelers Often Recommend Renting a Car in Iceland
One of the most repeated themes on r/visitingiceland is freedom.
A rental car lets you:
- Adjust plans based on weather
- Visit places tours skip
- Travel at your own pace
- Save money on day trips
For value-focused travelers, renting with Thrifty offers a practical way to explore Iceland without paying premium prices.